“Perhaps the finest California Pinot I have ever had the pleasure of drinking.”
Allen Meadows (Burghound) on 2004 Rivers-Marie Summa Vineyard Old Vines Pinot Noir
Summa Vineyard was first planted in 1979 by Steve Young on a beautiful ridge top site on Taylor Lane west of
the town of Occidental six miles inland from the Pacific coastline on the true Sonoma Coast. Various published
sources have incorrectly dated the original plantings to 1975, 1978 (preparation of the Summa Vineyard site for
planting occurred in 1978), or 1980. As a reference in time, David Hirsch planted his first vines at Hirsch
Vineyard in Cazedero located in the more northerly Sonoma Coast about the same time (1980).
The original approximately 2 acres of vines, which included Pinot Noir, Chardonnay and Gewürztraminer, were
planted to 8‘ x 12‘ spacing. The first vines were soon all grafted over to Pinot Noir. Scott and Joan Zeller
acquired the vineyard in 1982, live on the property, and have dry-farmed the vineyard to the present time.
The original clones of Pinot Noir planted at Summa Vineyard have been a source of conjecture through the
years, as the Zellers either do not know or decline to disclose the plant material origins. Burt Williams, who
crafted Summa Vineyard Pinot Noirs from the 1988 to 1997, suspects the old vines are original Swan clone
In 1998, an additional 3 acres of Pinot Noir were added on resistant rootstock from old vine cuttings and these
plantings are referred to as young vines. In 2000, more Pinot Noir vines (again old vine cuttings) were
interplanted among the old vines. In 2005 and 2009, an additional 1.5 acres of Pinot Noir was established
(also old vine cuttings), known as the Driveway Block, located on Zeller’s current residence property and now
leased back to Thomas Rivers Brown, who bought the 1979-2000 Summa Vineyard plantings in September
2010. The recent photo below shows Thomas Brown (leaf pulling) and Scott Zeller in the Summa Vineyard.
This second photo shows a row of original old vines with a row of newer young vine interplantings on the right.
Thomas Rivers Brown, who has become a successful winemaker for numerous prestigious Cabernet
Sauvignon producers at the Black Sears and Outpost facilities on Howell Mountain, was given his first
winemaking job by Ehren Jordan at Turley Wine Cellars. In 2002, Ehren fortuitously introduced Thomas to
Scott and Joan Zeller. Ehren had made his first two barrels of vineyard-designated Pinot Noir from Summa
Vineyard in 1999, but was not able to rely on that source and had subsequently turned to other sites in the
Sonoma Coast region for grapes by 2002.
After meeting Thomas, the Zellers offered him some grapes, but Thomas had no money in 2002 to launch a new Pinot Noir label, and jokes, “Genevieve Marie Walsh (his
spouse) and I didn’t have two nickels to rub together.” However, Thomas knew the reputation of the Summa
Vineyard, could not pass on the opportunity to make wine from this legendary source. He relented and crafted his first
Rivers-Marie Summa Vineyard Pinot Noir in 2002. Thomas’s propitious decision was to be confirmed two
years later when he tasted the 1988 Williams Selyem Summa Vineyard Pinot Noir. Thomas was to remark, “I
never tasted anything like it before from California.”
The first wines from Summa Vineyard were produced by the tiny Sea Ridge Winery (now defunct). In the late
1980s, Burt Williams and Ed Selyem were riding their motorcycles in the hills west of Occidental looking for
suitable grape sources when they came upon Scott Zeller and Summa Vineyard. Zeller agree to sell them fruit
and the first Williams Selyem Summa Vineyard Pinot Noir was released in 1988. The wine was highly lauded
and brought Summa Vineyard instant recognition. Yields were typically miniscule and in 1989 and 1990 no
usable grapes were harvested. In 1991, a total of one ton of grapes was harvested from the two acres which
produced two barrels of wine. The cost of the grapes worked out to be $5,000 per ton when the farming costs
for three years (two of which - 1989 and 1990 - yielded no grapes) were considered.
The Williams Selyem 1991 Summa Vineyard Pinot Noir was offered to the mailing list at $100 a bottle, the first
California Pinot Noir to sell for this lofty price. Williams figured that if people wouldn’t buy it, he and Ed would
take it all home and drink it. Williams said about the wine’s price, “C-note or c-none.” The wine sold out in
three days. This wine, along with the 1995 Williams Selyem Summa Vineyard Pinot Noir, were among the personal
favorites among the many wines that Williams produced over the years at Williams Selyem.
Williams Selyem released a Summa Vineyard Pinot Noir in 1988, 1991, 1993 (a combined Summa Vineyard-
Coastlands Vineyard bottling was also produced in this vintage) 1995 and 1997. In 1988-1990 and 1993-1995,
declassified lots of Summa Vineyard grapes were sometimes a component of the Williams Selyem Sonoma Coast bottling. The 1995 Summa Vineyard Pinot Noir sold for $125, and sold out again within days. The 1995
Summa Vineyard Pinot Noir was a prodigious wine. In the 1997 Williams Selyem Fall Mailer, Ed Selyem’s
tasting notes were compelling: “Need a dictionary for adjectives. In the last four years, I’ve re-tasted practically
all the best producers’ grand cru red Burgundies for vintages well over a decade including 1985s and 1990s.
I’m sorry, without prejudice, there has been nothing close to this wine.”
After Williams Selyem was sold in 1997, grapes from Summa Vineyard went to Mueller Winery
(1998-2000), Brogan Cellars (1998-2006), and Littorai (2002-2008). With the acquisition of Summa Vineyard
by Rivers-Marie in 2010, the vineyard became a monopole exclusive to Rivers-Marie. Thomas now produces a
Summa Vineyard “Young Vines” and “Old Vines” Summa Vineyard Pinot Noir in most vintages. Declassified
lots are blended into the Rivers-Marie Sonoma Coast bottling.
A number of prominent vineyards have been planted on Taylor Lane near or adjacent Summa Vineyard
including Taylor Lane (Pinot Noir to Boèhme and Belle Glos), B. Theiriot (Chardonnay to Littorai and Rivers-
Marie, Pinot Noir to Littorai), La Boèhme (a monopole for Red Car Wine Co.), Carl Meyer and Occidental (Pinot
Noir to Evening Land), Taylor Ridge, Que Syrah and Maybach.
On June 13, 2012, I organized a retrospective tasting of Summa Vineyard Pinot Noirs. The event was held at
Healdsburg’s Dry Creek Kitchen, and a number of notable winemakers attended including Thomas Rivers
Brown, Burt Williams, Nikolai Stez (Woodenhead), Ben and Yolanda Papapietro (Papapietro-Perry), Ross Cobb
(Cobb Wines & Hirsch Vineyards), and Kerith Overstreet (Bruliam Wines).
There were a number of stunning wines in the 18 bottle lineup including the 2004, 2007, 2009 and 2010 Old
Vines from Rivers-Marie, the 2002 Summa Vineyard and 2006 Michaela’s Reserve from Brogan Cellars,
the 2003 and 2005 Littorai wines (a combination of old vines and new vines), and the 1995 from Williams
Selyem, which Burt generously donated (one of his last two 750 ml bottles). It was one of the most spectacular
Pinot Noir tastings I have ever attended.
The 1995 Williams Selyem Summa Vineyard Pinot Noir was the consensus favorite of those in attendance.
Now 17 years old, the wine was incredibly fresh, in part attributable to its remarkable acidity. Burt noted that at
harvest the grapes had the following readings: 24.5º Brix, pH 3.09 and TA 0.99. The wine at bottling (Burt
never acidified) showed the following: 13.9% alc., pH 3.29 and TA 0.964. There was no stem inclusion and the
wine spent 16 months in 100% new Francois Frères French oak. The price upon release as noted previously
was $125 and total production was 52 cases.
Since Margi Weirenga-Williams and Ted Lemon could not attend, I do not have winemaking details for the
Brogan Cellars and Littorai wines. The Brogan Cellars wines tended to be bold and richly structured, the
Littorai wines (a combination of fruit from both old vines and new vines) more restrained and savory. The winemaking regimen for
Rivers-Marie was detailed by Thomas as follows. Grapes undergo a cold soak, light punchdowns and spend
18 days on the skins. No acid bumps or additions. No whole cluster (10% in 2010). Aged 10 months in
80%-100% new oak (Remond in 2002 and 2003, Remond and Francois Frères in 2004-2010). Production in
2002 and 2003 was 2 barrels from 0.7 tons of fruit. The wines are unfined and unfiltered (and show a very
slight resulting cloudiness). The Young Vines and Old Vines bottlings share some similarities, but the Old
Vines has a broader palate and more depth due to vine age. It is always a wine to contemplate.
Thomas is quite taken by the Old Vines wines from Summa Vineyard. He noted in his newsletter offering the
2009 vintage: “We’ve run out of original things to say about this wine. Every year we try to figure out where the
current bottling ranks among previous editions and this year I am at a loss. I finally have to admit I simply love
this vineyard and the wine it produces and leave it at that. There’s really nothing we’ve come across that
tastes like it.”
My tasting notes of Summa Vineyard wines are summarized below.
2002 Rivers-Marie Old Vines Summa Vineyard Sonoma Coast Pinot Noir
14.1% alc., 44 cases. Aged in
100% new French oak.
Very light garnet color in the glass. Aromas of cherry, red berry, orange peel, leather
and oak. Light and elegant flavors of red strawberries, blood oranges and a hint of oak with slight tannin and
bright acidity. Holding, but fruit is beginning the downslope.
2003 Rivers-Marie Old Vines Summa Vineyard Sonoma Coast Pinot Noir
13.5% alc., 44 cases. Aged in
100% new French oak.
Very light garnet color in the glass. Brighter aromas of dark cherries and sandalwood.
Elegant, but more body than the 2002 vintage, with pleasing flavors of red berries, cherries, pomegranates,
and subtle oak. Fine-grain tannins and some length. Has peaked but will hold a few more years.
2004 Rivers-Marie Old Vines Summa Vineyard Sonoma Coast Pinot Noir
14.1% alc., 60 cases. Aged in
100% new French oak.
Moderately light reddish-purple color in the glass. Aromas of oak spice, wood
shavings and conifer. Tasty core of black cherry fruit with a complimentary hint of oak. Well-structured and still
showing some fine-grain tannin, finishing dry with a tart cherry flourish.
2005 Rivers-Marie Old Vines Summa Vineyard Sonoma Coast Pinot Noir 14.1% alc., 1 new quarter barrel,
54 bottles. Not tasted.
2006 Rivers-Marie Old Vines Summa Vineyard Sonoma Coast Pinot Noir 13.7% alc., 62 cases. Aged in
100% new French oak. Not tasted.
2007 Rivers-Marie Old Vines Summa Vineyard Sonoma Coast Pinot Noir
13.4% alc., 100 cases, $60.
Aged in 100% new French oak.
Moderately light reddish-purple color in the glass. Beguiling aromas of fresh
black cherries and spice. Very soft in the mouth, with a delicious core of medium-weight flavors of perfectly
ripe cherries and baking spices. Really impresses with depth of flavor which seems to expand into every
crevice in the mouth. Well-proportioned tannins and acidity with amazing length on the glorious finish. Poised
for many years of exceptional drinking ahead.
2008 Rivers-Marie Old Vines Summa Vineyard Sonoma Coast Pinot Noir
14.1% alc., 175 cases, $60.
Aged in 100% new French oak.
Moderately light reddish-purple color in the glass. On the nose, dark fruits are
featured including plums and black cherries with a hint of ash and lime. Delicious black cherry core with very
slight creosole and smoke flavors. Moderate dry tannins and very impressive length on the finish.
2009 Rivers-Marie Old Vines Summa Vineyard Sonoma Coast Pinot Noir
13.2% alc., 106 cases, $60.
Aged in 80% new French oak.
Medium reddish-purple color in the glass. Restrained aromas of black cherries,
black plums and seasoned oak. Richly flavored red and black fruits accented with notes of spice, herbs and
oak. Very soft in the mouth with a bright cut of acidity on the very long finish. Makes a lasting impression. Still
young and hasn’t reached its full potential.
2010 Rivers-Marie Old Vines Summa Vineyard Sonoma Coast Pinot Noir
13.0% alc., 137 cases, $75.
Aged in 80% new French oak. Yields just shy of 1 ton per acre.
Moderately light reddish-purple color in the
glass. Big, bold aromas of dark berry jam and black cherries with a hint of dark caramel. Luscious and creamy
on the palate with a wave of rather exotic ripe dark berry and plum flavors with hints of spice and toasty oak.
Well-balanced tannins and acidity with a long, layered, fruit-filled finish so typical of this vineyard. Tempting
now, but best to wait another 3 to 5 years.
2002 Brogan Cellars Old Vines Summa Vineyard Sonoma Coast Pinot Noir
reddish-purple color in the glass. Fresh and holding well with vibrant aromas of dark cherries and toasty oak.
Moderately rich flavors of dark red berries and cherries, wrapped in gossamer tannins, and finishing with a
fresh, uplifting note of cherries and peppercorns. Still has several years of life ahead.
2003 Brogan Cellars Old Vines Summa Vineyard Sonoma Coast Pinot Noir
13.9% alc.. Aged in 75% new
Moderate reddish-purple color in the glass. Very ripe fruit profile with aromas of black plum sauce
blackberry jam, and spice. Full-bodied flavors of cassis and currant with notes of brown spice and sassafras.
Still showing adequate tannic support for the prodigious fruit.
2004 Brogan Cellars Young Vines Summa Vineyard Sonoma Coast Pinot Noir
14.1% alc., 150 cases,
Moderate reddish-purple color with slight bricking of the rim in the glass. Moderately dark reddish-purple
color in the glass. Shy aromas of grilled plums and toasty oak. Flavors of dark cherries and plum sauce with
hints of raisin, fruit leather and oak. Excellent acid spine, but the tannins dominate the fruit.
2006 Brogan Cellars Michaela’s Reserve Summa Vineyard Sonoma Coast Pinot Noir
14.6% alc., $110.
The last Brogan Cellars Pinot Noir from Summa Vineyard. Crafted from young vines. Named for Margi’s
granddaughter born in 2006. Aged 15 months in 50% new French oak.
Moderate reddish-purple color in the
glass. Enticing aromas of black cherry liquor and vanillin oak. Layered and flashy on the palate with delicious
flavors of well-spiced redder fruits which cling to the lengthy finish. Beautifully balanced with a dreamy mouth
feel. A special wine with years of life ahead.
2002 Littorai Summa Vineyard Sonoma Coast Pinot Noir
14.4% alc., $65. Sampled a week after the
tasting (the wine was misplaced in my cellar and I found it after the tasting).
Nicely perfumed with aromas of
exotic dark berries, old book, pipe smoke, oak and dried rose petals. Very intensely flavored with waves of wild
red berries, caressed by notable but balanced tannins, finishing strong and long with a hint of smoky, herbal
oak and a touch of heat. Still fresh and alive and will last several more years. Very good.
2003 Littorai Summa Vineyard Sonoma Coast Pinot Noir
13.9% alc., 85 cases, $65.
color in the glass. Very fragrant with scents of dark berries and cherries, spice, and conifer. Delicious
core of dark red raspberries and blueberries with a hint of baking spice and herbs. Soft tannins and velvety on
the palate. Outstanding, showing the balance to last another 10 years.
2005 Littorai Summa Vineyard Sonoma Coast Pinot Noir
14.2% alc., 24 cases, $80.
color in the glass. Similar to the 2003 vintage but with more intense fruit aromas augmented by hints of
wooded forest and savory herbs including sage. Discreetly concentrated core of vivid dark red berries
wrapped in soft tannins. Very seductive with a satiny smooth mouth feel. Many years ahead.
2006 Littorai Summa Vineyard Sonoma Coast Pinot Noir
13.7% alc., 121 cases, $80.
reddish-purple color in the glass. Exotic and nuanced aromas including cherries, earth, flowers and stainless
steel. Middleweight flavors of savory deep red berries caressed by ripe, dry tannins and lifted by a good cut of
acidity. Holding nicely.
2008 Littorai Summa Vineyard Sonoma Coast Pinot Noir
13.5% alc., $80.
Moderately light reddish-purple
hue in the glass. Flavorful fruit core of black cherries, black raspberries, but suffers from a subtle smoke, tar
and creosote flavor. Well-crafted as always by Ted Lemon, but smoke taint ruins the experience for me.
1999 Mueller Summa Vineyard Sonoma Coast Pinot Noir
Dark reddish-purple color with rim
bricking and sediment in the glass. Aromas of leather, tea and leaf. Moderately rich flavors of blackberries,
black tea and cola with imposing tannins which overwhelm the fading fruit. Past its prime.
1995 Williams Selyem Summa Vineyard Sonoma Coast Pinot Noir
13.9% alc., 52 cases, $125.
reddish-purple color in the glass with no rim bricking. Unbelievably fresh and alive with impressive aromatic
and flavor power. Scents of brandied cherries, tea leaf, and sassafras. Elegant and smooth on the palate,
offering delicious flavors of cherries, baking spices, rose hips tea and subtle oak which persist on the bright
finish. Didn’t even consider spitting this one out. A rare glimpse of the convergence of a remarkable vineyard
and the genius of a legendary winemaker.
Shortly before the tasting, Margi (Brogan Cellars) notified me of her inability to attend due to family
commitments. At the last minute, I contacted my friend, Kerith Overstreet, M.D., who has been crafting Pinot
Noir and Zinfandel under the Bruliam label for a few years, and she was able to fill in. A relatively new and
humble winemaker who recently moved to Healdsburg, she wrote a very humorous piece about her experience
at the tasting on her blog titled “The Luckiest Girl in the World.” I have reproduced her blog entry here for your enjoyment:
The Luckiest Girl in the World
Posted: 17 Jun 2012 10:14 AM PDT
If you live in Los Angeles, you’ll eventually come across a celebrity. You may find
yourself cross legged beside Gisele Bundchen during Mommy & Me class at the kinder
gym. Perhaps you’ve indulged in a manicure alongside Jessica Simpson or sidled past
Pam Anderson at the plastic surgeon’s office. It’s a law of averages. Here in Sonoma
County the currency is less reality TV diva and more celebrity vintner. (Notwithstanding a
purported Giada de Laurentiis sighting at the last summer Farmer’s Market; apparently I
missed her phone message.) I have heard winemaker Merry Edwards is a devoted yogi,
but I’m too lazy to drive to the studio in her neighborhood. I doubt either the Kosta or
Browne contingency buys wine at Costco. But, it’s bound to happen here too- that
elusive celebrity winemaker sighting. It may even emerge from the most mundane and
inauspicious of circumstances, like an 11th hour Hail Mary phone call.
I fielded a call last Wednesday at 8:58 am, as I was rushing to drop the kids at summer
camp. It was a good friend and well known wine reviewer asking if I wanted to join him
at a high end pinot noir tasting starting at 10 am. Some last minute cancellation
relinquished a vacancy at the tasting table. Might I enjoy a morning of fine wine? High
end, single vineyard pinot at 10 am? Hell yeah, count me in. I asked if I should bring
wine or something to share. He said to just show up. So I did, about 15 minutes late (I
had to stop at the post office). Then my head exploded.
It turns out I had Forrest Gumped into a private tasting of verticals from Summa
Vineyard, a legendary Sonoma Coast property way out in West County. The tasting
featured five different wineries each using pinot noir fruit from the same 6 acre site, with
wines dating back to 1995. I arrived, fashionable late and took the only open seat
behind a forlorn, phalanx of empty stemware. The phase one tasting included 7 wines
from the same producer, spanning 2002-2010. Eleven additional Summa Vineyard wines
rounded out phase two. I am not one to name drop, but this was a serious who’s who of
Sonoma Coast pinot noir. Imagine an Academy Awards of Superstar Celebrity Vintners
kind of event. I was totally star struck. I used every ounce of professional restraint to
keep my camera phone stashed in my purse.
To my right was a lovely older gentleman in a Hawaiian shirt. He smiled, stuck out his
hand, and said, “I’m Burt. Good to meet you.” I looked at him and said, “I know exactly
who you are, sir.” The company was as awe inspiring as the wines. You cannot pay any
amount of money to taste such rare stuff side by side. I’d stumbled into a carefully
curated private tasting. I was a lucky interloper. One winemaking celebrity mistook me
for a sales rep for another winery. At least he didn’t ask me to serve him some crackers.
Now for the wines. Allow me to preface this by reminding you that I am not an amateur
wine reviewer. I’m worse. I pride myself on my failure to identify a Rioja from left-bank
Bordeaux blind. But, I will share my notes from my three favorites, in descending order
of jaw-dropping awesomeness.
#3) 2007 Rivers-Marie Summa Old Vines Sonoma Coast Pinot Noir
“Color is more red and less brick than ‘02/’03, nose with integrated baking spice,
allspice, clove, exotic spice, cherry, raspberry, blood orange, tastes of fruit and spice,
still quite bright with nice acid.”
#2) 2006 Brogan Michaela’s Reserve Pinot Noir Sonoma Coast Pinot Noir
“Love it! Sexy and seductive nose with floral notes, red cherry, cherry candy and some
oak flavors on the finish; nice spice on a long finish. This wine is plush and giving.”
Now to blow your mind, no friggin’ joke:
#1) 1995 Williams-Selyem Winery Sonoma Coast Summa Vineyard Pinot Noir
“Holy crap! Color is still red; no brown tinge. Nose is plummy and perfumed, cherry, tea,
fresh sage, and thyme. Wow! Still has crazy structure and tannin. Vibrant.”
Like I said, I don’t like to drop names, but Burt Williams borrowed my pen.