Book Review: Is This Bottle Corked?
This is just the kind of off beat book about wine that you might find very interesting. No chapters about what to
drink, how to drink, how to match food with wine, and other tiresome wine preaching. Rather, this book offers
138 somewhat obtuse but fascinating questions about wine. The authors, Kathleen Burk and Michael Bywater,
are not wine gurus or critics, but rather wine lovers who have an interest in the historical perspective of wine.
The result is a book with an academic tone, offering short and straightforward answers that fascinate rather
than bore the reader.
Examples of questions posed include, “What did Jane Austen recommend for headache?” (Answer: Constantia
wine), “Did Benjamin Franklin really produce a ‘sprightly claret?” (Answer: He gave instructions on how to
make wine in the Colonies in the 1743 edition of Poor Richard’s Almanac), “What was Napoleon’s favorite
wine?” (Answer: Clos Vougeot and Chambertain), and “Was Pliny the first Robert Parker?” (Answer: No 100-
point scale, but he was unrivaled as a wine scholar of his time). There are a number of other questions
answered which will enrich anyone with an interest in wine such as, “Who first invented wine,” What is terroir,
and should we care,” and “Should wine be decanted.” Because the short chapters are devoted to one
question, the reader can pick up the book for short periods of time and thumb to a question of interest without
reading the book from front to back. Wine writers will find the book a special resource of historical facts.
The authors come from different backgrounds. Kathleen Burk is a Californian whose family were winegrowers
and while at the University of California at Berkeley, she spent considerable time in the Napa Valley tasting
wine. She is an accomplished author, has written for the World of Fine Wine, currently the world’s most
sophisticated and highly lauded wine publication, but also is well-versed in history and a Professor of Modern
and Contemporary History at University College London. Michael Bywater has written numerous articles for
periodicals in the UK, is a regular broadcaster for the BBC, and teaches tragedy at the University of
Cambridge. The pair’s diverse backgrounds and interests provide the right mix for a lively read about “The
Secret Life of Wine.”
Published by Random House, Inc., 208 pages, hardcover, 2009, $19.99.