Williams Selyem: A California Icon
I look back on the early 1990s and remember liking California Pinot Noir practically labeled me an eccentric.
To most wine lovers of the time, Pinot Noir was an afterthought, a weak substitute for Cabernet Sauvignon and
Merlot. For me, Pinot Noir was the Holy Grail, the most sensual of all wines, and I was staunchly determined
to pursue my love affair with it.
It was the Pinot Noirs of Williams Selyem that culminated my courtship. Burt Williams and Ed Selyem were
able to produce magical Pinot Noirs out of a small garage on Fulton Road in Santa Rosa. The original Pinot
Noir garagistes, they crafted magical wines from vineyards that are now revered like Rochioli, Allen, Hirsch and
Olivet Lane. It was a 1992 Williams Selyem Rochioli Vineyard Pinot Noir that made such a powerful
impression on me that even today I can taste the wine, and clearly believe it was the greatest California Pinot
Noir I have ever had in my life.
Burt Williams lived in Forestville, worked as a printer for the San Francisco Newspaper Agency (the
Chronicle and Examiner), and made wine at home. Ed Selyem was a wine buyer and salesperson who crafted
beer and fruit wine in his garage in Forestville. Together, they began making wine from Sonoma Zinfandel
grapes for their own use in 1979. They started making wine commercially in 1981 at Russian River Valley
Vineyards in Forestville and bottled the Pinot Noirs under the Hacienda del Rio label, a name Ed used on his
first home-crafted wines. The photo below on the left shows a 1980 Hacienda del Rio label from a wine
produced in Burt's Forestville garage but not released commercially. The 1981 to 1983 Hacienda Del Rio label
looked exactly like the current Williams Selyem label, using the same letterpress letters, color and paper
(below right). A complaint from Hacienda Winery prompted the partners to drop the original name and
substitute Williams Selyem beginning with the 1984 vintage. In 1984 they had moved to a rented garage on
River Road in Fulton, becoming true "garagistes."
Williams was a burly vintner who had a superb palate and an uncanny and self-taught sense of how Pinot Noir
should be vinified (photo below left). He never set foot in Burgundy. Early on, production methods were old fashion
and labor intensive due to a lack of capital. In the early years, Williams continued his job in San
Francisco as did Ed at Speer’s Market in Forestville, and they took vacations at crush time to make the wines. They began
with little money, never borrowed, and grew 25% every year by starting small and plowing all of their income
back into the business. Spouses Gayle Selyem and Jan Williams were also partners in the winery which early
on hired no outside help. It was a perfect business partnership with Burt driven to make world-class wine and
Ed determined to create a successful business from local agriculture. Burt preferred colorful sport shirts with
suspenders, Ed opted for tee shirts and boots. Both lived simply and shunned publicity. There was never a
sign at the garage announcing the winery’s location, and there was never a tasting room.
The secret to their success, and this has become the model for all prestigious producers of California Pinot
Noir today, was to carefully chose their grape sources and perform all the work in the winery themselves. Over
time, North American vintners have come to realize that Pinot Noir requires delicate handling and constant
vigilance in the winery, two things Ed and Burt practiced from the beginning. Their winemaking techniques were
very labor intensive, but the result justified the effort. The Williams Selyem Pinot Noir were brimming with
varietal character, and although light in color, they had superb aromatic and flavor intensity.
The more wine Williams Selyem made, the more favorable the press that followed, causing a snowball effect in
demand. The 1985 Williams Selyem Rochioli Vineyard Russian River Valley Pinot Noir became the most
seminal wine in the history of California Pinot Noir. This wine won the Sweepstakes at the California State Fair
Wine Competition, voted the best of the 2,136 wines entered by 416 wineries in 1987. 295 cases of this wine
were produced and it sold for $16 a bottle.
Williams Selyem became so popular that a waiting list was developed for those begging to get on the mailing
list. Eventually, 85% of the wine was sold directly to individuals on the carefully guarded mailing list. Ed
managed the list masterfully and enjoyed being in contact with, visiting with, and learning from devoted
customers. The customers were among the most devoted of any other winery I have experienced then and
now. Chris Crevasse of Tennessee wrote, “We are a little concerned about my brother-in-law, who had never
tried world-class wine until we shared a bottle of your 1991 Olivet Lane Pinot Noir with him. Now he’s lost
interest in work and has moved the La-Z-boy downstairs in the wine cellar. He claims he just wants to watch,
but it’s hard to say what need watching down there. We’re all hopeful that he’s just displaying the initial zeal of
a new convert, and that he return to a more normal life once he gets accustomed to venerating your wine.”
Williams Selyem Pinot Noirs were amazingly fruity and complex when young and seemed to age better than
most California Pinot Noirs of the time. The wines peaked around 6 to 7 years after release, but it was difficult
to avoid drinking them young. The unlikely owners and the scarcity of their wines created a mystique, but it
was the wines’ quality and consistency that was the attraction. Win Wilson and Jack Daniels, the Napa Valley
importers of Domaine de la Romanee-Conti came calling to Williams Selyem in 1992. They wanted to
compare wines. 22 wines and 5 hours later, no conclusions were publicly reported, but the reason to do such a
comparative tasting indicated the cachet that Williams Selyem had gained with the wine industry.
The popularity of Williams Selyem wines took its toil over the years on Ed and Burt. Managing the mailing list
and the hoards of wine enthusiasts trying to get on the list became a daunting task. Two of the winery’s seven
full-time employees in the mid 1990s were designated as “keepers of the list,” and devoted their work day to
managing it. The partnership slowly developed some rife and Williams Selyem was put on the market in 1997.
It was sold to John Dyson, a long time member of the Williams Selyem mailing list in 1998 for a reported $9.5
million. The official word was that Ed developed serious back problems from lifting cases of wine over the
years, but the reasons had to be more complicated, yet were never divulged. The last vintage that Ed and Burt
vinified at Williams Selyem was 1997, with Burt consulting on the 1998 vintage. At the time the winery was
sold, there were 10,000 customers on the mailing list and many more on the waiting list.
John Dyson, a wealthy New York politician, was a former New York State agriculture commissioner and a
former deputy mayor under Mayor Rudy Giuliani. He owns Millbrook Vineyards in upstate New York and Villa
Pillo Estate in Tuscany as well as Mistral and Vista Verde vineyards on the Central Coast of California. Dyson
essentially paid a fortune for the Williams Selyem name only since Ed and Burt did not own vineyards or a
physical winery. Dyson lost some of the hand shake agreements that existed for grapes from Olivet Lane
Vineyard, Summa Vineyard, and Rochioli’s West Block, but several of the vineyard sources such as Allen
Vineyard, Ferrington Vineyard and Hirsch Vineyard were retained.
Upon purchasing the winery, Dyson hired the relatively unknown winemaker, Bob Cabral. Cabral, who was
Williams Selyem customer number 576 on the mailing list, was the son of grape farmers. He had earned a
degree in enology at California State University at Fresno and learned his trade at DeLoach Vineyards, Knude,
Alderbrook, and Hartford Court. Since assuming winemaking responsibilities, Cabral has followed many of
Williams’ winemaking methods. After an inauspicious start (it is always difficult to follow a legend), he is
producing an exceptional lineup of appellation-based and vineyard-designated Pinot Noirs that are still eagerly
sought after. The wines are now a little higher in alcohol, deeper in color, and offer more intense fruit-driven
flavors, but they have received consistent praise from the wine press and the winery continues the tradition of
excellence began almost thirty years ago.
Finishing touches are being applied to the new Williams Selyem production facility at the Litton Estate on
Westside Road. Crush activities still take place at the nearby Allen Ranch but the production barrel rooms that
are built into the hillside are finished and the bottling line was in place for the 2008 vintage. Solar panels
supply much of the winery’s electric power and rooftop gardens help insulate the new building.
I recently tasted through most of the lineup of the 2007 Williams Selyem Pinot Noirs. These wines have now
spent some reasonable time in the bottle allowing for proper critical evaluation. The wines met all of my
preconceived expectations considering the accolades bestowed on the 2007 vintage, This vintage was recently
declared “Vintage of the Decade” by Wine Enthusiast magazine, whose Pinot Noir wine reviewer, Steve
Heimoff, awarded the 2007 Williams Selyem Litton Estate Vineyard Russian River Valley Pinot Noir ($100) a
score of 100, matching its price, becoming the first California Pinot Noir ever given such a lofty score. The 2007 growing season in California was marked by moderation and evenness. Bud break was uneventful in March, the summer was warm and sunny with very few heat spikes resulting in uniform ripening. The harvest of Pinot
Noir began in early September and was interrupted by fog and cool weather in the middle of the month,
followed by a leisurely paced harvest of the rest of the crop which benefited from the extended hang time.
According to Williams Selyem,”In a decade of exceptional vintages, this one really stands above all others.” I
did not review the Litton Estate Pinot Noir from a winery-owned 19-acre vineyard or the Central Coast, Sonoma
Coast and Sonoma County bottlings.
The wines were all darkly colored with admirable balance, excellent integration of oak, and appealing
aromatics. They are solid wines, and while several stir emotion, a few don’t deliver at the price point.
2007 Williams Selyem Russian River Valley Pinot Noir
14.1% alc., $45. Primarily sourced from the winery’s
Drake Estate Vineyard planted in 1998. Pommard and Dijon 115.
Heady aromas of Bing cherries, cola and
baking spice. Reasonably concentrated flavors of dark red cherry and berry fruit which build in intensity in the
glass. Very pleasing in the mouth with soft tannins and a crisp finish. Very good.
2007 Williams Selyem Flax Vineyard Russian River Valley Pinot Noir
14.2% alc., $54.
A signature Russian River Valley Pinot nose perfumed
with nicely spiced berry and cherry compote with an echo of oak. Very
tasty panoply of red berries and cherries intensely composed like a
flavorful liquor. Juicy with a smooth viscous mouth feel, supple tannins
and perfect balance. A great wine that reminds me of old vintages of
Williams Selyem and one of my favorites in this lineup.
2007 Williams Selyem Peay Vineyard Sonoma Coast Pinot Noir
The nose lack sensory impact but offers demure aromas of redder
fruits and crushed rocks. Elegantly composed and shy in generosity of flavor
but offering pleasing notes of dark red cherries and cranberries, mocha and
spice. Has the balance to age and certainly will become more expressive with
time in the cellar. Very good (+)
2007 Williams Selyem Vista Verde Vineyard San Benito County Pinot Noir
13.9% alc., $54.
offers an interesting array of scents including fresh berries, black currants, vanillin oak and stem. Moderately
rich middle palate of cherry and berry fruit with a hint of citrus bringing up the rear. Bright and juicy with
moderate persistence on the finish. Solid but not spectacular. Very good in this vintage.
2007 Williams Selyem Weir Vineyard Yorkville Highlands Pinot Noir
14.3% alc., $56.
This wine takes on more muscle and interest with time
in the glass. The nuanced aromatic profile features dark stone fruits,
spice, oak and toast. Deep, dark but charming fruit is wrapped in firm
tannins and balanced acidity. A virile wine of great intensity that has
multiple layers of fruit and perfect harmony.
2007 Williams Selyem Ferrington Vineyard Anderson Valley Pinot Noir
13.9% alc., $62.
of crushed cherries, berries and sweet oak. A rich, full-bodied and tasty fruit-driven wine with a little acidic tang
on the finish. The tannins are reigned in creating a silky drinking experience. A bit one-dimensional but the
sappy fruit flavors will find many fans. Very good.
2007 Williams Selyem Westside Road Neighbors Russian River Valley Pinot Noir
13.8% alc., $67. A complex blend from the best growers on
Westside Road including Allen, Bacigalupi, Bucher, Flax, Rochioli Riverblock and
Brooding aromas of dark stone fruits, spice and vanilla. Opens
somewhat in the glass but never offers a big dose of fruit. Full-bodied,
magnificently flavored core of cherries, cranberries, and raspberries pulled into
line by fine acidity and ripe tannins with a subtle accent of sweet oak. A little
closed and not what it will be. Decant if you must drink now. Very good
2007 Williams Selyem Coastlands Vineyard Sonoma Coast Pinot Noir
14.3% alc., $69.
reddish-purple color in the glass. Intense aromas of blackberries, black plums, Indian spices, loamy earth and
green garden with a hint of alcohol peaking out. Unctuous, tannic, rough hewn and muscular on the attack
featuring smoky dark fruits and a citrus underpinning. Needs food, preferably short ribs. Decent.
2007 Williams Selyem Hirsch Vineyard Sonoma Coast Pinot Noir
14.3% alc., $72.
Starts off strong in the
glass with alluring floral and red berry scents, fading over time revealing more savory, earthy accents.
Delicious and generous lasting flavors of deep red cherries and berries pulled into line with fine grain tannins
and bright acidity revealing itself in a citric peel highlighted finish. Not a huge or loud wine, but very satisfying.
2007 Williams Selyem Rochioli Riverblock Vineyard Russian River Valley Pinot Noir
13.9% alc., $75.
Very alluring scents of cardamon
spice, rose petals and Bing cherries. An impressive wine with a
discreetly concentrated cherry and berry core augmented with Xmas
spice, vanilla and an undertone of minerality. The silky texture is dreamy
and the overall impression is one of purity, vibrancy and harmony. This is
clearly the class of the lineup and will definitely find a place on my 2010 All
2007 Williams Selyem Allen Vineyard Russian River Valley Pinot Noir
13.8% alc., $78.
of wild berries and plums. Earth-laden dark fruits with a hint of tea and root beer. Rich and husky but not
showing much chutzpah now. Smoothly textured and well-crafted but dull. I expect more from this bottling and
perhaps it will improve with time in the cellar. I didn’t have a second bottle to sample. Decent (+).
2007 Williams Selyem Precious Mountain Vineyard Sonoma Coast Pinot Noir
14.4% alc., $90.
Delicate aromas of dark stone fruits and
blackberries. A hulk of a wine with prodigious dark fruit that coats the
mouth with intensity. A wonderful sipping wine that will charm any big fruit
lover. Hard to keep you hands off now, but cellaring will provide dividends
down the road. This wine definitely stands out from the pack.
Williams Selyem wines are primarily sold to an eager and faithful mailing list of customers. With the recent
economic downturn, some of the wines have been more available to those not on the mailing list (inquire by
phoning the winery). The wines are readily available on the secondary market at a small premium over the
release price. There are two offerings. The spring offering brings primarily the appellation Pinot Noirs and
Westside Neighbors bottling while the fall offering includes all the single-vineyard Pinot Noirs. High quality
Chardonnay and Zinfandel are also produced. The informative website is at www.williamsselyem.com. Maps of
all the sourced vineyards are included. Videos of Russian River Valley pioneers are also offered including
interviews with Howard Allen, Helen and Charles Bacigalupi, Jim and Andrew Forchini, and Joe Rochioli. The
James Beard winning video on the Russian River Valley produced by Grape Radio is also available for viewing.