Chardonnay: What Gives In PinotFile?
Ok, I have come out of the closet. I have another paramour: Chardonnay. You will notice the first appearance
of the “Golden Geek” and “Golden Value” icons in this issue, and like their Pinot Noir counterparts, represent
the best in Chardonnay (Golden Geek) and the best values in Chardonnay (Golden Value).
As of late, many Pinot Noir producers have also been sending me their Chardonnays to review, especially after
they find out that I enjoy and drink Chardonnay regularly as my white wine of choice. That is not to say that the
PinotFile will taken on a “bi” proclivity. The overwhelming emphasis will forever remain on Pinot Noir.
Chardonnay is not a true part of the Pinot family of Pinot Noir, Pinot Gris and Pinot Blanc, but as shown by
researchers at University of California at Davis in 1999, is most likely derived from a fling in the distant past
between Gouvais Blanc and Pinot Noir.
The early plantings of Chardonnay in California in the 1970s were primarily Wente clone. In 1912, a member
of the Wente family took cuttings from the University of Montpellier viticultural nursery in France and planted
them in the Livermore Valley of California. Cuttings from the Wente vineyard then spread to many wineries and
eventually the Wente clone was certified by the Foundation Plants Material Service at University of California at
Davis. The clones from certified vines are called “Wente clone” or UCD 4. The clones taken before
certification are called “Old Wente” and designated 2A. Thus, not all Wente clones are the same, and older
vineyards in California planted to Old Wente are highly prized.
The Wente clone is moderate yielding and shy-bearing, producing a rich mouthfeel, and aromas and flavor
tones of tropical, floral and Muscat notes with nutmeg and clove spice.
The Dijon clones of Chardonnay were brought to North America by the Oregonians, who found that the Wente
and Draper clones from California performed poorly in Oregon, failing to ripen and producing wines that were
thin, acidic and lacking in character. As a result of the efforts of vintner David Adelsheim and others beginning
in 1974, Dijon clones were eventually widely introduced in Oregon and produced Chardonnays with excellent
structure and balanced acidity. The Dijon clones matured before the bad weather set in at the end of Oregon’s
harvest, proving to be a better match to Oregon’s climate.
The early Dijon Chardonnay clones were certified in 1997 (75, 76, 96 and 98) and 1988 (77, 95, 277). As of
2006, 34 clonal varieties of Chardonnay were planted in vineyards throughout France, most of which were
Dijon clones developed at the University of Burgundy. Dijon 76, 95 and 96 are said to produce more flavor-concentrated
clusters, Dijon 77 and 809 more aromatic wines with a “grapey” perfume, and Dijon 75, 78, 121,
124, 125 and 277 are more vigorous and higher yielding. These clones provide Chardonnays with citrus, stone,
melon and tropical aromas and flavors.
There are a number of other clones and/or selections that have appeared through the years in California. The
Hanzell clone came from Wente clone cuttings at Stony Hill in Napa Valley. This clone is shy-bearing and
known for millerendage or “hens and chicks,” clusters of grapes with some normal-size berries, but many small
and seedless berries. This phenomenon is more exaggerated in the Hanzell clone than in other Old Wente
plantings in California and confers a distinction on Hanzell Chardonnay (see pages 1-10 in this issue).
Still other Chardonnay varieties include the Robert Young selections, Draper (Ridge), Mt. Eden, Monticello,
Sees (Miramar Torres), Hyde, Hudson, and Musqué, made famous at Matanzas Creek and representing
several different mutations of the Chardonnay grape that produce Muscat-like or floral aromas.
Some of California’s most prized Chardonnay vineyards include Hyde and Hudson in Carneros, Heintz in the
Sonoma Coast (25 acres of clone 4 on AXR1 planted in 1982), Ritchie in the Russian River Valley (Musqué
and Wente planted in 1972), Hirsch and Marcassin in the Sonoma Coast, Durell on Sonoma Mountain (some
Old Wente clone planted in 1979) and Kistler (Old Wente and Mt. Eden clones. Kistler also has some Old
Wente planted at Vine Hill Vineyard, McCrea Vineyard and other newer vineyards).
The most promising appellations for Chardonnay in California? Santa Rita Hills has to be at or near the top of
the list, yet most producers here prefer to concentrate on Pinot Noir. I would love to taste some Chardonnay
from the Sta. Rita Hills AVA crafted by Ted Lemon, Steve Kistler or Helen Turley. Other appellations that have
shown exceptional metal include the Santa Cruz Mountains, Carneros, Sonoma Coast, and Mendocino Ridge.
The aromas and flavors of barrel-fermented Chardonnay derive not only from the fruit itself, but from malolactic
fermentation, oak barrel aging and the terroir of the vineyard source. Malolactic fermentation produces tones
of butter, creme and hazelnut, light oak leads to tones of vanilla, coconut, and sweet wood, heavy oak imparts
tones of oak, smoke and toast, and terroir is reflected in tones of flint, minerals, and mint. Stainless-steel
fermented Chardonnay has fans as well, with its proponents touting the pure expression of the fruit and terroir.
Matching food with California Chardonnay? It will, of course, depend on the style of Chardonnay, but I often
turn to fritto miso, pommes frites, caesar salad, potato chips, buttered and salted popcorn, and of course,
lobster with drawn butter. Try grilled butterflied leg of lamb as well and you will be surprised.
I reviewed the following Chardonnays in the past couple of months. California Chardonnay, unlike Pinot Noir, is
more dependable with better examples at lower price points. High-end producers like Marcassin, Peter
Michael, Kistler, and Kongsgaard can demand close to $100 a bottle, but when you taste these wines, you can
readily appreciate the quality difference compared to lesser-priced examples. Once you get hooked, the habit
will be an inescapable draw on your pocketbook. It is one of the facts of life: great wine costs money. That
said, there are many California Chardonnays in the value-priced range that can offer perfectly satisfying
drinking on a daily basis without impugning your credit score.
The current pantheon of Chardonnay producers includes: Aubert, duMOL, Hanzell, Kistler, Kongsgaard,
Littorai, Marcassin, Mount Eden, Pahlmeyer, Paul Hobbs, Peter Michael, Ramey and Stony Hill. There are
many other wineries nipping at their heels, as shown by the reviews below of Chardonnays tasted in the past
2007 Pahlmeyer Napa Valley Chardonnay
14.9% alc., $40. Pahlmeyer has run into a bit of a financial pinch
of late and you can find their wines heavily discounted.
Golden yellow color in the glass. Appealing aromas of
lemon curd, light caramel, butter and toast. Soft and strikingly creamy on the palate with flavors of white
grapes, white peaches, brioche and toasty oak. Plenty of tannin and acidity to balance the prodigious fruit. A
consistent favorite among fans of California full-on Chardonnay. Very good (+).
2007 J Vineyards Russian River Valley Chardonnay
14.3% alc., $28.
Light straw colored in the
glass. Toasty oak and sawdust dominate the green apple aromas. Very tasty glazed apple and pear
flavors with underlying notes of light caramel, brioche and oak. California-styled with plenty of oakderived
aromas and flavors that will find favor with many Chardonnay lovers. Good.
2007 Robert Stemmler Estate Grown Carneros Chardonnay
14.1% alc., $25. Clones are Old Wente,
Weimer and Dijon. Whole cluster pressed, cold fermented, aged in 40% new French oak, stirred on its lees,
Light yellow in color in the glass. Has the aromas and flavors of an older wine and this bottle may
be slightly oxidized. On the nose, poached pear and shoe box are noted and the flavors veer toward roasted
peach, kumquat and grilled apricot with accents of caramel, brown sugar and stewed apple. Moderately rich,
very smoothly textured and easy to drink. Decent.
2004 Littorai Charles Heintz Vineyard Sonoma Coast Pinot Noir
Moderate straw color in the
glass. Shy perfume of lemon tart, espresso and oak toast with a hint of funk that dissipates with time in the
glass. Tasty flavors of lemons, Asian pear and coffee with a subtle note of oak-derived burned marshmallow in
the background. Plenty of finesse and well proportioned acidity. Like most of Ted Lemon’s wines, they don’t
come to you, you have to seek out the nuances. Very good (-).
2007 Peirson Meyer Charles Heintz Vineyard Sonoma Coast Chardonnay
14.4% alc., 450 cases,
$55. The companion label of l’Angevin named after the two proprietor families, Robbie (winemaker with
stints at Lewis Cellars and Peter Michael) and Shannon Meyer, and Alan and Lesley Warner Peirson.
Barrel fermented, wild yeast fermentation, 100% MLF, aged 15 months in 50% new French oak, unfined
Moderate straw color in the glass. The aromas really come at you over time in the glass
showing lemon curd, creme brulee, vanilla wafer and wet stones. Flat-out delicious flavors of golden apple,
pear, melon and freshly buttered brioche that are palate staining and hang around on the finish for what
seems like a minute. Very smoothly textured with perfect integration of oak. This wine would make any
Frenchman green with envy. My favorite Chardonnay from California and one I buy by the case and in
magnums when my wife isn’t looking over my shoulder. Wowza! (Also drank a bottle in 2012 and was equally wowed).
2007 Freestone Vineyards Ovation Sonoma Coast Chardonnay
14.0% alc., $45. 61% estate grapes, 21%
Dutton Ranch, 18% Bacigalupi Vineyard. Aged 15 months in 60% new and 40% two to three-year-old French
oak barrels. Weekly stirring of the lees before MLF. Freestone’s node to California-styled Chardonnay.
golden yellow color in the glass. Demure aromas of lemon curd, pear, white peach and a steely minerality that
carries over on the palate. Delicious core of citrus and pear flavors with complimentary notes of caramel,
baking spices and a citrus tang that persists on the refreshingly dry finish. Very good.
2007 Three Saints Santa Maria Valley Chardonnay
14.1% alc., pH 3.09, 3,000 cases, $20. Whole cluster
pressed, native and inoculated fermentations. Initial fermentation is finished in barrel and partial MLF occurs in
barrel. Twice weekly lees stirring. Lightly fined and unfiltered.
Crisp, juicy and refreshing with aromas and
flavors of lemons, white peaches, pears and oak. A little sweetness on the finish is not my cup of tea, but this
style will have many fans. A solid choice for short-term daily drinking. Decent.
2007 Bonterra Vineyards Mendocino County Chardonnay
13.0% alc., pH 3.27, $12, screw cap.
96% Chardonnay, 3% Muscat, 0.5% Rousanne, 0.5% Viognier. Made from organic grapes and aged
in primarily neutral French and American oak. The winemaker is Robert Blue.
Very pale yellow-green
in the glass. Appealing aromas of lemon curd, banana, vanilla and oak toast. Discreetly rich and soft
in the mouth with flavors of citrus fruits, creme brulee and vanilla wafers. A bit hollow in the mid-palate
and becomes less interesting in the glass over time, but a value-priced play that will work well when
mildly chilled at the dinner table. Good.
2007 LIOCO Sonoma County Chardonnay
14.5% alc,, $20, screw cap. Fermented in stainless steel
using wild yeast. Aged in tank 5 months on lees. Bottled unfined and unfiltered.
Pale yellow color with
slight haze in the glass. Aromas of lemons, honey, yeast and popcorn. Luscious and full-flavored with
bright crunchy fruit that jumps out of the glass. Accents of roasted nuts, pears, honey and nutmeg add
interest. Smoothly textured with bright acidity. The essence of Chardonnay. Good (+).
2007 Lucas & Lewellen Santa Barbara County Chardonnay
13.7% alc., $18. Stainless steel
fermented grapes from younger vines at Los Alamos and Goodchild vineyards in northern Santa
Clear pale yellow color in the glass. A nice little Chardonnay with typical varietal
aromas of pears, white peach, melon, lemon and cut flowers. The flavors echo the aromas with a slight
grassy, herbal and resin flavor. Soft and crisp in the mouth. Good.
2007 Morlet Family Vineyards ‘Ma Douce’ Sonoma Coast Chardonnay
360 cases, $70. From a vineyard on the second ridge from the Pacific
Ocean. Dedicated to Luc Morlet’s spouse, Jodie, and named ‘My Sweet’ or
‘Ma Douce.’ Native yeast, 100% MLF, weekly batonnage. Unfiltered.
Moderately deep straw yellow color in the glass. Piercing aromas of lemon curd,
yeast, roasted nuts and smoky oak. Plush and luxurious on the palate, yet vibrant
with acidity and minerality. Enticing flavors of white peach and buttered brioche
linger on the refreshing finish. A very impressive wine that was still pumping out
bright flavor three days later from an opened, re-corked and non-refrigerated bottle.
Decant this wine if you pop the cork now. One of the greatest California Chardonnays to cross my lips. Sold
out at the winery and understandably so. Still available through retail channels on the internet.
Morlet Family Vineyards
This newer winery has been widely acclaimed by Robert Parker, Jr., and Steven Tanzer and
rapidly took on a cult image shortly after its founding in 2006. Morlet Family Vineyards is the
project of Luc and Jodie Morlet who handcraft vineyard designated wines and unique cuvées from
vineyards in Napa Valley and Sonoma County, several of which they have long-term contracts with
and direct the farming.
Luc Morlet is a fourth generation, France-born wine maker who grew up on his family's domaine in
Champagne. He worked in vineyards and wineries in Burgundy and Bordeaux before venturing to
California. There he became winemaker for Newton, Staglin and Peter Michael Winery, where he
still consults to his brother, Nicolas, who succeeded him as full-time winemaker.
Besides the 'Ma Douce,' there is a 'Ma Princesse' Russian River Valley Chardonnay and the
'Coup de Coeur' Sonoma County Chardonnay which represents the best barrels of the vintage
and consists of only 75 cases. The Chardonnays are based on Old Wente clones and are styled
similar to the Chardonnays from Peter Michael. In addition, there are three Sonoma Coast Pinot
Noirs, each of which is produced in 100 case lots, a Sauvignon Blanc, Muscadelle and Semillon
blend named 'La Proportion Doree,' a Bennett Valley Syrah, three Cabernet Sauvignons from
Napa Valley, and a Late Harvest Semillon from Alexander Valley.
I met Luc Morlet at a special wine dinner at Charlie Palmer at Bloomingdale's in Costa Mesa's
South Coast Plaza on April 14, 2010. Both Peter Michael and Morlet Family Vineyards wines were
featured along with the cuisine of Amar Santana. My favorite course was Sonoma quail stuffed
with sweet Italian sausage, sweet pea puree and braised morel jus paired with the 2008 Morlet
'Côteaux Nobles' Sonoma Coast Pinot Noir. I will review all the Morlet Pinot Noirs in an upcoming
Morlet Family Vineyards wines are sold primarily through a mailing list at www.morletwines.com
with some fine restaurant distribution and very limited retail sales. For those of you shut out of the
Peter Michael mailing list, this is a perfect opportunity to hop on board the Morlet mailing list.